Q: My luxurious apartment constructing in Manhattan has fallen into disrepair, and the board of managers is thwarting efforts to enhance it. Over the previous 10 years, we’ve been unable to succeed in a quorum for the annual assembly, which has prevented any new candidates from becoming a member of the board or voting for any actual adjustments. The board declares there’s a scarcity of quorum, however attendance isn’t taken. The president has been there for the reason that board started, greater than 35 years in the past. Obligatory work is awarded to questionable contractors, and there have been rumors of impropriety. For instance, the board distributed a memo saying a $100 penalty for every bit of correspondence distributed inside the constructing, equivalent to fliers in public areas or underneath doorways. Homeowners’ efforts to prepare have been rebuffed. What can we do?
A: The board of managers has a fiduciary responsibility to all homeowners, and there are a number of avenues you may take to attempt to get higher management. No matter step you are taking, just remember to adhere to your condominium’s bylaws and to state regulation to make sure a outcome that stands as much as authorized scrutiny.
Your bylaws should comprise a provision, underneath New York’s Condominium Act, permitting unit homeowners to take away a board member, together with standards for doing so. That is usually executed by means of a particular assembly, which might be referred to as by a board president or by way of a petition signed by a sure share of unit homeowners.
Condominium boards’ selections are virtually all the time protected by the enterprise judgment rule, which makes it “extraordinarily troublesome” for a unit proprietor to problem the board in court docket, mentioned Ronald H. Gitter, an actual property lawyer in Manhattan. For that reason, he mentioned, calling a particular assembly to take away a board member for violating the governing paperwork is probably going your only option.
Boards usually are not protected by this rule in the event that they act with gross negligence or in dangerous religion. “That may apply to the fines imposed for distributing communications to different residents about board conduct,” mentioned Ruta Behrend, a associate at Tane Waterman & Wurtzel P.C.
You may ask for an inventory of contacts for unit homeowners, and talk with them in the identical technique that the board does. (Remember the fact that boards don’t want homeowners abusing the checklist.)
You can too file a lawsuit towards the board, claiming that it has breached its fiduciary responsibility, however this might be a costlier, prolonged course of. For a doubtlessly faster outcome, you possibly can ask a court docket to nominate a receiver to supervise constructing operations and bills.
“It’s step towards preserving everybody’s funding within the constructing,” mentioned Steven D. Sladkus, a associate at Schwartz Sladkus Reich Greenberg Atlas LLP in Manhattan.
For weekly e mail updates on residential actual property information, sign up here.